Best quality blank / recordable DVD's.

10 posts / 0 new
Last post
Fat Marty
Best quality blank / recordable DVD's.

Hello,
I am preparing to convert my irreplacable home movies from video tape to DVD for posterity. I am hearing about DVD rot and delamination. Can anybody guide me about the best quality brand of disks to use? Any brands that should be avoided? Thanks.

Jeff Block
Interesting article on the

Interesting article on the subject at: http://www.manifest-tech.com/media_dvd/dvd_compatibility.htm.

Can't speak from personal experience though, since I haven't had a DVD-R long enough to be affected. From what I understand, though, the writable DVD is one of the items that fits under the "You get what you pay for" heading.

Ron Repking (not verified)
Matt wrote a great article

Matt wrote a great article about this at www.techlore.com/article/10284

Fat Marty
Thanks for the information


Thanks for the information guys, that was very helpful. Maxell replied to my e-mail and said that they use Azo dye in their disks which seems to be one of the better dyes accoring to the article referenced above.

Matt Whitlock (not verified)
Azo is a good choice for

Azo is a good choice for archival, considering they have a good archival life and can be safely written to at higher speeds. However, if you've got a good quality burner and software that can adjust recording speeds, like Nero Burning ROM, pthalocyanine will last longer if you plan on never reduplicating these videos to a future format.

Ron Repking (not verified)
Would love to hear about your

Would love to hear about your experiences converting your tapes to DVDs, the selections that you made along the way, and any trouble that you ran into as I'm sure the community would too.

Fat Marty
I have also read that


I have also read that pthalocyanine is an excellent choice, however I do not know which DVD+R manufacturers use pthalocyanine in their disks. Can anyone help?
I ordered my Dell computer with the DVD burner preinstalled. So far I have only burned DVD's from my Sony digital camcorder. I haven't tackled the VHS to DVD conversion yet.

Matt Whitlock (not verified)
Pthalocyanine is usually

Pthalocyanine is usually pretty easy to pick out. Discs are commonly silver and gold, since the dye formulation is basicly clear. Also, the odd colored discs (like red) are usually a silver reflection layer, pthalocyanine, and a red colored plastic shell. When picking a disc by color, you must verify that the plastic on the disc is clear. After that, you can usually figure it out by the color of the disc.

To help further, I use a small program that reads the ATIP information of a blank CD or DVD called CD-R Identifier. It provides lots of cool info about a blank disc, and best of all, it's freeware! You can download it here.

Fat Marty
Matt, I have read about the

Matt,
I have read about the different colors of the various dyes. However, with the DVDs sealed in packages at the store I cannot verify the color without opening the pack. The manufacturers don't bother to print it on the pack. I would like to know before I buy what I am getting. Do you know for sure who uses Pthalocyanine? Thanks.

Matt Whitlock (not verified)
There's two ways you can

There's two ways you can approach it, because it's not always easy to find out this kind of info.

1. See what friends, family, and neighbors use. They've already bought a pack, so you could check one out that way.

2. Visit the manufacturer's website. Oftentimes they show a disc out of the package, so you ay be able to get a look at the color. Remember that rewritable discs use a much different structure, so don't focus on dyes when shopping for rewritables.

3. I always recommend experimenting. While the dye can tell you a lot about what to expect from a disc, it can't tell you everything. Buy a disc off of a friend, or small packages in stores and experiment. This way you'll be able to find discs that work best for you, and one more compatible to your home video products. Don't be afraid of Azo and Cyanine, they do work well, and can be written a high speeds, and are often cheaper. Plus, many of the big corporations have their own formulations of cyanine, which are often stabilized using other compunds for better archival life than cyanine alone.

To get you started, Mitsui (MAM-A disc brand) is the patent holder for pthalocyanine technology. If you want to try a good pthalocyanine disc, I'd try theirs first. Amazon has a good deal on a 50 pack of their silver DVD-R discs. The link is here.

 

Connect With Techlore